Percentage of Negligence

Percentage of Negligence

If you get injured in a traffic accident in Japan and someone else is to blame for your injury, you deserve compensated for your damages. However, what if you partially negligent for the accident? In this case, your total compensation is reduced in proportion to your percentage of negligence. If the total of your damage costs JPY10,000,000 and your percentage of negligence is 30%, you only deserve getting JPY7,000,000. That is a big financial difference especially when your damage is huge. So the percentage of negligence is always one of the biggest issues when both parties have an argument about compensation. In this article, we take a closer look at what it is and how we determine it.

What is the "Percentage of Negligence"?

When a car accident happens in Japan, the responsibility for the accident is based on the Percentage of Negligence of both parties. However, in most cases, a car accident is not by one negligent person, but some other people including a victim is also negligent. In this case, an at-fault driver doesn’t have to recover the victim’s all the damages but has to recover the damages in proportion to the percentage of negligence. In Japan, the percentage of negligence means a percentage of responsibility for the accident. That is supported by the Japanese Civil Law Act. 722 (2). If a victim is negligent as well as an at-fault driver, the court may determine the amount of compensation by taking that factor into consideration.

The standard for Designation of Percentage of Negligence

The percentage of negligence is not sensuously determined by both an at-fault driver and a victim. There is an official standard for designation determined based on past legal precedents. You can check the standard in the book of the "Calculation standard of compensation for traffic accident " published by Nichibenren Traffic Accident Consultation Center. It's available only in Japanese.

Insurance companies refer to the standard. Judges refer to it as well. So if you don't reach an agreement on the percentage of negligence with the other party, check the standard to see whether your point is adequate. By doing so, you can check the possibility of whether you win when going to court.

Following you can find some typical examples:

(1) The collision between a pedestrian and a car in a crosswalk.

StatusPercentage of the negligence of the pedestrian
A pedestrian using a crosswalk when a traffic light is green was hit by a car going through the crosswalk even when a traffic light is red.0%
A pedestrian using a crosswalk when a traffic light is yellow was hit by a car going through the crosswalk even when a traffic light is red.10%
A pedestrian using a crosswalk when a traffic light is red was hit by a car going through the crosswalk when a traffic light is green.70%

(2) A rear-end collision in an intersection

Accident StatusPercentage of Negligence
The car A going ahead when a traffic light was green and car B going ahead when a traffic light was redA ----  0 %   B ----100%
The car A going ahead when a traffic light was yellow and car B going ahead when a traffic light was redA ----20 %   B ----80 %
The car A going ahead when a traffic light was red and car B going ahead when a traffic light was redA ---- 50 %   B ----  0 %

Note that these examples are just a simple version of the whole of the tables. The book contains various cases: 1) a pedestrian and vehicle; 2) a vehicle and vehicle; 3) a motorcycle and vehicle; 4)a bicycle and vehicle, and 5) accidents on the highway. It refers to the basic percentage of negligence depending on cases. It also refers to occasions we should increase or reduce the percentage of negligence.

How the percentage of negligence affects the amount of compensation

The concept of “Percentage of Negligence” is applied to any of the compensation occurring in a car accident. The following table is an example when the percentage of negligence of a victim is 20%.

 DamageCompensation for an opposite partyPayment for their own damageSum of payment
Victim$10,000$5,000*0.2=$1,000$10,000*0.2=$2,000$3,000
At-fault driver$5,000$10,000*0,8=$8,000$5,000*0.8=$4,000$12,000

Difference $9,000

As you can see from the table, not only the victim but also the at-fault driver has damages in many cases. If the victim is negligent as well, he/she also has a responsibility to compensate for the damages of both of them. In the above-indicated case, the total cost the victim has to pay for damages is $3,000 while that of the at-fault driver is $12,000. So the at-fault driver has to pay the difference of $9,000 to the victim as compensation.

 
Related

We are Senryaku Corp. Contact us freely. Click the following icons. In addition to the above apps, Wha[…]

How to contact us